MULAN JOURNAL / 06 DIALOGUE
On Making: Drawing Mulan as a Single Line
He drew 12 sketches for Mulan Maison and kept only one line.
Editor's note: This piece records the visual making of Mulan Maison. At the designer's request, they are identified only by their role — "visual design", fourteen years at the work.
First Version: 12 Sketches
Q: When the brief "Mulan" first landed, what was your first reaction?
A: Dodge. The word "Mulan" has been drawn too many times already — on horseback, in armour, red tassel, war banner. Every version was handsome; every version looked like somebody else's.
Q: So how did you begin?
A: I drew every element I could think of — a full 12 sheets. Horse, armour, sword, banner, moon, mountains, hair bun, figure seen from behind… Then I laid them all out on the table and looked for a long time.
The conclusion: not one could be used. They all describe what Mulan did; not one says who Mulan is.
The Turn: Remove Everything Literal
Q: So what did you do?
A: I changed the question. If Mulan could only be expressed in one stroke, what should that stroke be?
I sat with it a long time. What came to me was not a shape but a motion. In "galloping off", the strongest thing is neither the horse nor the rider — it is the diagonal running upward from below, too fast to be reined back. It is the posture of "setting out" itself.
Q: So what stayed in the end was a single line.
A: A line with acceleration. It runs from lower left to upper right, thickening and thinning, lifting slightly at the tip. No horse, no armour, no banner. Yet people who see it instinctively read "she is setting out".
It does not describe what Mulan did.
It says who Mulan is.
Execution: How Many Tests One Line Must Pass
- Angle — The slope is fixed at 32 degrees. Any flatter reads weak; any steeper reads overwrought. The number came out of forty-odd drafts — there is no formula.
- Weight — It starts at 0.6 and ends at 1.2, in relative stroke units. The middle must not be even; even, it becomes a geometric figure and stops looking like a brush.
- Horizontal compression — On mobile the line gets squashed, so a steeper derived angle was made, used only on narrow screens.
- Ground — The line only holds on a warm black ground. On white it turns frivolous, because white gives it no weight.
- Where the gold goes — The line itself takes no gold. Gold traces only the start of the stroke, a tiny close. Any larger and the whole mark collapses.
On Resemblance
Q: Will some people say this doesn't look like Mulan?
A: They will. And that is a necessary price. A mark you recognize at a glance is usually a mark you forget at a glance.
What I want is the slower effect: first sight, abstract; second sight, familiar; by the tenth, you are already using the line to stand for Mulan. Only then has it truly become a symbol.
Three Lines for Anyone Building a Brand
- One — Draw everything you can think of first, then be brave enough to use none of it. The first round of ideas is almost always somebody else's.
- Two — When you find that "one stroke", it will usually look so simple you suspect yourself of laziness. Don't. That is the one.
- Three — The simple mark costs the most. It cannot hide its flaws in detail; every judgment lies in the open.
Afterword
Not one of the 12 sketches was adopted in the end. But none were thrown away — they now hang in the second-floor corridor of Mulan Maison, laid out in order, with the 13th piece being the line.
At the end of the corridor, one sentence: draw every wrong road first; only then do you know which one is right.
TO TASTE · A cup from the same source
Mulan Collections · Bespoke Gifting
From mark to objects, the same subtraction. Corporate gifting, co-branding and favours all begin from this line.
Visit the Shop ↗MULAN JOURNAL, written slowly.
Volume One has twelve pieces, one every two weeks. Leave your email and the next piece comes straight to you.